This Butter Chicken Mac and Cheese combines creamy, three-cheese mac and cheese with bold Indian-inspired makhani sauce and tender tandoori chicken. Made with a homemade roux-based cheese sauce, this baked mac and cheese is rich, flavorful, and perfectly scoopable with a golden, cheesy top. It's the ultimate comfort food!
In a mixing bowl, combine yogurt, ginger garlic paste, lemon juice, oil, Kashmiri chili powder, garam masala, coriander, cumin, turmeric, and salt. Add chicken and toss until thoroughly coated.
Cover and refrigerate for at least 30 minutes, ideally 2–4 hours or overnight.
Step 2: Cook the chicken
Remove chicken from the refrigerator about 15 minutes before cooking.
Heat a large cast-iron skillet over medium-high heat with a little neutral oil. Working in batches, add chicken in a single layer. Avoid overcrowding the pan.
Cook on both sides until deeply browned on the outside and cooked through to an internal temperature of 165°F. Transfer to a plate and let rest for a few minutes.
(Grill) Preheat the grill to high. Skewer the chicken and cook on all sides until charred and cooked through, around 8-10 minutes.
Step 3: Prepare the makhani sauce bomb
In the same pan, heat butter over low to medium heat. Add ginger-garlic paste and bay leaf and sauté for 30–45 seconds until fragrant.
Add tomato paste and cook for 3-5 minutes until it darkens slightly. Add a splash of water if it starts to burn.
Stir in the Kashmiri chili powder, garam masala, coriander, cumin, onion powder, green cardamom, and clove. Bloom the spices for about 30 seconds.
Pour in tomato puree and salt. Simmer uncovered for 12–15 minutes, stirring occasionally, until thickened and the raw tomato flavor has cooked out. The fat will start to separate on the sides when it's ready.
Remove the bay leaf. Add the sugar. Crush the kasuri methi between your palms into the pot. Finish with 1 tablespoon butter.
Yield = 1 cup of concentrated makhani sauce. Set aside for the mac and cheese.
Step 4: Prepare the pasta
Preheat oven to 350°F. Butter a 9-by-13-inch baking dish.
Bring a large pot of salted water to a boil. Cook the pasta according to boxed instructions until about 1 minute shy of al dente. It will continue cooking in the oven.
Drain and set aside.
Step 5: Make the makhani cheese sauce
While the pasta boils, combine the shredded mozzarella, Colby Jack, and cheddar cheeses in a large bowl. Divide the cheese mixture in half.
In a large saucepan or Dutch oven, melt butter over low to medium heat. Add flour and whisk continuously for 2–3 minutes to create a roux.
Once the roux slightly darkens, slowly pour in evaporated milk, whisking constantly until smooth and thickened.
Add 1 cup of the prepared makhani sauce and whisk until evenly incorporated. Add heavy cream. Continue whisking.
Reduce heat to low. Gradually add half of the shredded cheese mixture, stirring until melted and smooth with each addition.
Taste the sauce before proceeding. If the tomato is overpowering, add a little more cream.
Add cooked pasta to the cheese sauce and toss until every piece is coated.
Step 6: Assemble
Transfer half of the mac and cheese into the prepared baking dish. Scatter half of the cooked chicken over the pasta. Sprinkle with a generous layer of shredded cheese.
Add the remaining mac and cheese. Scatter the remaining chicken over the top. Finish with the remaining shredded cheese.
Step 7: Bake
Bake uncovered at 350°F for 20–25 minutes, until the cheese is melted and bubbling around the edges.
Switch the oven to broil for 2-3 minutes to create a golden, bubbly cheese crust. Watch carefully. Remove from the oven and rest for 5–10 minutes before serving.
Serve immediately while the cheese is still gooey.
Notes
Shred your own cheese. Freshly shredded cheese melts more smoothly than pre-shredded cheese, which often contains anti-caking agents that can affect the sauce's texture.Keep the heat low when adding cheese. Once the roux and dairy have thickened, reduce the heat to low or remove the saucepan from the heat before gradually stirring in the shredded cheese. Never boil the cheese sauce, as high heat can cause it to become grainy or oily.Don't overcook the pasta. Boil the cavatappi about 1 minute shy of al dente. It will continue cooking in the oven and absorb some of the cheese sauce.Reduce the makhani sauce thoroughly. The sauce should be thick and concentrated before incorporating it into the cheese sauce. Keep the cheese sauce slightly loose. The pasta will absorb moisture as it bakes and cools. The sauce should look a little saucier than you want the finished dish to be.Avoid overbaking. The pasta and chicken are already cooked, so the oven is primarily melting the cheese layers and creating a golden crust. Bake just until bubbly, then broil briefly for color.Make ahead: Prepare the makhani sauce up to 3 days in advance and marinate the chicken for up to 24 hours. Refrigerate both separately until ready to cook.Storage and reheating: Refrigerate leftovers in an airtight container for 3–4 days. Reheat gently with a splash of milk or cream to loosen the cheese sauce and help prevent it from becoming oily.