This finger-lickin' Butter Chicken is the dreamiest creamiest Indian curry that you can make in the comfort of your own home, even down to the iconic bold orange-red color. This recipe is beginner-friendly, yet rivals your favorite restaurant's Chicken Makhani. It's best when indulged with basmati rice or homemade garlic naan.
If you are new to Indian cuisine, you're probably guilty of ordering Butter Chicken with Garlic Naan and Mango Lassi. It's the typical, safe go-to order. Honestly, it's my takeout order, too. It's undeniably all the best parts of Indian cuisine.
However, I've been told that my homemade Butter Chicken recipe is better than most restaurants. At this point, I've made it dozens of times for a weeknight dinner or while hosting friends. It's even easier to make ahead with my Easy Baked Butter Chicken recipe. I translated my love for it into Butter Chicken Wings and Butter Masala Pasta right here on Masala and Chai!
This Chicken Makhani recipe is lightly spicy and layered with flavor. I'll walk you through all the steps to get a beautiful silky smooth bright red makhani! It's actually quite easy to make at home. However, you may need to check that you have a well-stocked spice cabinet before you make this recipe. No worries, nothing a quick trip to the Indian grocer can't fix!
I can't wait for you to blow your family and friends away by serving up this authentic, world famous dish! Serve it with Samosa Chaat to start and alongside a few other of my favorite dishes like Dahi Vada, Chili Paneer, and Aloo Methi Sabji. Just like a restaurant, each guest takes a little of each dish on their plate and enjoys it with rice or naan.
Jump to:
Why You'll Love this Recipe
Butter Chicken is about to become your favorite go-to weeknight dinner for the family! I promise your kids will ask you for homemade Butter Chicken rather than heading to the Indian restaurant. Here's why you'll love my well-tested recipe:
- I give you options. If you don't want to buy all the whole spices, that's totally fine. It will be just as delicious without them. Although I really encourage you don't skip the green cardamom. And if you don't even want to make your own quick DIY tandoori masala, I show you how to adjust boxed butter chicken masala.
- I'll help you orchestrate all the moving pieces to create this dish - marinating the chicken, making the makhani, blending the makhani, searing the chicken, and finishing off the curry. All the while providing you with process photos at each step and telling you why you're doing that step.
- We use the Indian cooking process called bhuna which extracts and deepens the flavors of the curry. It's this process and the brilliant red yet mild Kashmiri Chili Powder that creates a orangey red curry without artificial food coloring.
What is Butter Chicken?
Butter Chicken is also known as chicken makhani or in Hindi as murgh makhani. It is an Indian curry made with a base of a spiced tomato gravy with plenty of butter (makhan) and yogurt-marinated chicken that's traditionally cooked in a tandoor. It's famous for its bold red-orange color, silky smooth creamy texture, and rich flavors.
You may think Butter Chicken is centuries old, but it really came about in the mid-1900s! In the 1950s, Kundan Lal Gujral, the founder of restaurant Moti Mahal in New Delhi, developed this world-famous dish on accident by combining leftover tandoori chicken with a tomato-based gravy with butter, or makhani (Source: Moti Mahal Cookbook). You can still visit the restaurant today to try their famous creation.
Today, we see Butter Chicken served not only by itself but in burritos, on top of pizzas, nachos, in wraps, and more. This dish has truly become world famous for its richness and bold flavor. And it's not without some drama and a lawsuit to determine who can lay claim to the true origins of this dish!
From Butter Chicken came Chicken Tikka Masala and while similar, they are not the same dish. Butter Chicken has its origins in India and uses more butter, while Chicken Tikka Masala is a British dish with a more concentrated tomato flavor.
Ingredients - Notes and Substitutions
Whew, okay. The recipe may feel like a hefty amount of ingredients, I admit it! Butter Chicken is, in my opinion, not that much effort to make. But to make it well, you need quite a few whole and ground spices. All of the ingredients are common to a well-stocked Indian kitchen. Let's go through them.
If, for some reason, the spices aren't accessible, then I'd highly recommend the MDH Butter Chicken Masala, which can be found online or at the Indian grocery. Use a quarter of the box for the marinade, and another quarter for the makhani sauce. I adjust the MDH masala with an additional 1 teaspoon garam masala, ⅛ teaspoon ground cloves, ½ teaspoon cumin, ½ teaspoon freshly ground green cardamom, and ½ teaspoon coriander to the makhani sauce.
The Marinade
Lightly charred, flavorful marinated chicken thighs add half of the flavor to the makhani! The chicken is marinated in dahi, ginger, garlic, lemon juice, and tandoori spices before it's baked in a tandoor, oven, or pan-fried.
- Chicken thighs - Specifically, chicken thighs. Chicken thighs are more forgiving than chicken breast which can easily become dry and overcooked in hot curries. Since Butter Chicken already has so much fat, be sure to trim off as much of the fat as possible before cubing it. You absolutely can use chicken breasts and sear them in a hot pan for some browning, and then transfer them to the sauce to finish cooking until tender.
- Dahi - Plain whole milk yogurt, like Indian dahi, is the best but you can use low-fat yogurt or Greek yogurt. Be sure to use the thickest parts of the yogurt, avoiding whey. Yogurt keeps the chicken super tender at high heat.
- Ginger garlic paste - Or as I call it, gigi paste! This is simply a 50/50 mix of ginger and garlic that's blended into a paste. You can easily make ginger garlic paste at home in a mortar and pestle or blender, or purchase it readymade.
- Green chilis - Indian green chili peppers or serranos add a bit of extra spice! Kashmiri chili powder is really mild and mostly for color and flavor so if you're a spice lover, this will punch up the heat. I like to deseed mine and then use a mortar and pestle to grind them up into a paste. It can be omitted.
- Spices - For the quick DIY tandoori masala, you'll need garam masala, ground turmeric, ground cumin, and kashmiri chili powder. Kashmiri chili powder adds the bright red color and is very mild in heat, but can be substituted with regular chili powder or paprika. Feel free to reduce the amount of chili powder. But this recipe is from an Indian kitchen! We love heat!
Butter Chicken Sauce
Arguably the best part, the makhani (butter and tomato-based gravy)!
- Butter - This is butter chicken. You need to use butter. Not a substitute like coconut oil. You can use unsalted butter (preferably) or ghee. Reluctantly, I'll also offer that you can use half butter and half oil as well.
- Whole spices - The whole spices are optional, but I add star anise, black cardamom pods, green cardamom pod seeds, a cinnamon stick, and cumin seeds at the beginning of the cook. It adds a ton of flavor to the dish and isn't the same without. You can substitute the cumin seeds with a ½ teaspoon ground cumin.
- My non-negotiable is green cardamom. I find that that it adds an indescribable layer of flavor to the sauce and I urge you to use it and experience it.
- Ground spices - We use garam masala, coriander, kashmiri chili powder, and my secret is the teeniest bit of ground cloves. You can also use 1-2 whole cloves instead of the ground spice and add it in along with the whole spices. But I hate fishing out the cloves or biting into one.
- Sugar - Butter chicken has a whooole lot of savory things going on. A bit of sugar helps balance it out.
- Tomato paste / canned tomatoes - The base of the makhani sauce is, of course, tomatoes. I use a tablespoon of tomato paste for the concentrated tomato flavor, and canned crushed tomatoes. You can also use fresh tomatoes when they're in season.
- I've tested this recipe using fresh tomatoes and while still delicious, the curry was extremely tangy. Unfortunately, out of season tomatoes in the U.S. aren't great for making curry. If you opt to use fresh tomatoes, boil 3 large tomatoes for 10 minutes and remove their skin. Then blend them until smooth.
- Heavy cream - For that signature creamy curry, use heavy whipping cream. Substitute it with coconut milk, cashew cream, or half and half.
- Kasuri methi - This is dried fenugreek leaves and is traditional to authentic butter chicken. It's ultimately optional but people swear it's the game-changing secret ingredient. Crush it between your hands before adding it directly in the curry. Substitute it with additional cilantro.
How to make Restaurant-Style Butter Chicken
I've broken down how to make Butter Chicken into 5 parts to orchestrate the timing of all the moving parts.
- Marinating the chicken
- Making the delicious makhani sauce that we all love!
- Cooking the chicken in a hot pan
- Blending the makhani into a smooth curry
- Finishing off the butter chicken
1. The Marinade
The chicken thighs need to marinate for a minimum of 30 minutes, or ideally overnight. Plan ahead if you want maximum flavor!
- Trim the fat off of the chicken thighs, and then cut them into 1-inch cubes.
- Mix the ingredients for the marinade - the dahi, lemon juice, ginger garlic paste, chopped green chilis, spices, and salt in a baker or large mixing bowl that will fit the amount of chicken you're making.
- Give the marinade a solid whisk until it's smooth and uniform. Then, add the chicken thighs into the marinade and mix until the pieces are evenly coated.
- It's best to throw on a pair of gloves and really massage the marinade into the chicken thighs, but you can also toss it together with a spatula for an even coating.
- Once that's done, cover the chicken with plastic wrap and refrigerate for a minimum of 30 minutes, and up to 24 hours.
This is a great point to start making the makhani sauce as the chicken marinates.
2. The Makhani Sauce
To make the makhani, we are using the Indian cooking technique referred to as bhuna, which is the process of roasting and frying ingredients in fat to extract and intensify the most flavor possible. The process darkens the base of the masala gravy until we're ready to add the seared chicken, resulting in that bold orangey red sauce.
- To start, melt 2 tablespoons of butter or ghee in a large pan or pot. While the butter melts, crush 4-5 green cardamom pods with a mortar and pestle or the flat of knife and remove the black seeds. Toss the green shells or save for a cup of chai. Once it's hot, add the star anise, black cardamom pod, cumin seeds, green cardamom seeds, and cinnamon stick for a minute to release their flavor.
- Then, add the aromatics - the onion and ginger garlic paste. Allow them to cook on a medium heat until the onion starts to lightly caramelize into a golden brown color. At that point, add the ground spices - garam masala, coriander, cloves, and kashmiri chili powder.
- Give it a good stir and sauté for a minute to let them bloom in the fat before adding the tomato paste and canned tomatoes. Add ½ teaspoon of salt (or to taste) and the sugar.
You can also add soaked cashews if you'd like it to be extra creamy and for the nutty flavor at this point.
- Lower the stove to a low to medium heat and allow the spices and tomatoes to simmer until it thickens and darkens significantly.
While it simmers - let's cook the chicken.
3. Cooking the Chicken
The chicken is traditionally cooked in a clay oven called a tandoor, which can reach temperatures up to 900°F. To get a similar effect without one:
- Heat a cast iron skillet on high heat with ghee or neutral oil - essentially any cooking oil with a higher smoke point.
- Once it's screaming hot, add in the marinated chicken. Cook on each side for 3-4 minutes until the chicken reaches an internal temperature of 165ºF and has crispy, charred edges. Once cooked, set the chicken aside.
Alternatively, bake the cubed chicken in a preheated oven at 350ºF for 16-18 minutes or until the internal temperature reaches 165ºF. Turn on the broiler for the last 5 minutes so the chicken gets crispy edges.
4. Blending the Curry
Back to the sauce!
We left off after lowering the heat to allow the sauce to thicken and darken significantly.
- You'll see some of the butter start to release on the sides and form small pools. This is exactly what you're looking for! Switch the heat off.
- Carefully remove and discard the star anise, black cardamom pod, and cinnamon stick.
- If you're using a glass blender, be sure to allow the curry to cool a bit to prevent the glass from shattering. Transfer everything to a high-speed blender, along with the other 2 tablespoons of butter.
- Blend the sauce until completely smooth, adding a tablespoon of water at a time until smooth and silky.
I've also tried using an immersion blender and the results weren't too great. The sauce was still chunky and it splattered everywhere. If you have a high quality appliance then go ahead and use that.
Note: If the texture is grainy after blending the sauce, that is okay! It is just the texture from the onions. Add a tablespoon of water at a time and continue to blend until you have a silky smooth sauce.
5. Finishing off the Butter Chicken
Note: If you'd like to add additional vegetables, like green bell peppers, then this is where you'd do that.
- Return the sauce to the pot. Turn the heat on to a medium low.
- Transfer in the cooked chicken with all of the juices from the pan. Toss it together with the sauce, and then continue to simmer the sauce with the lid on for a few minutes until the butter releases on the side again and the sauce is thick.
- Slowly add in the heavy cream while stirring. Avoid curdling heavy cream. Don't add the heavy cream in one go because it may curdle. Slowly stir it in.
- Remove the sauce from the stove and stir in a healthy pinch of crushed kasuri methi.
Pro Tip: If your butter chicken isn't saucy enough, add warm water or heavy cream. It may have simmered too long. You can also add more tomato sauce but you'll need to add more spices.
The Butter Chicken is ready to serve!
Serving Suggestions
Serve Butter Chicken in a karahi serving dish for a traditional restaurant look that can be passed and shared amongst family and friends. Garnish it with cilantro, a swirl of heavy cream, and finely diced red onion.
Butter Chicken is best when paired with garlic naan, classic basmati rice, or restaurant-style saffron rice. You can also serve it with the vegetarian version, Paneer Butter Masala, for more options.
If it's a bit too spicy, a side of Cucumber Raita is especially cooling.
Tips and Tricks
Here are a few tips to achieving the beautiful bold sauce:
- Use chicken thighs. They are more forgiving than chicken breasts. I've found that chicken breasts get way too dry and overcooked with hot curries.
- Fry the onion. Properly fry the yellow onion in unsalted butter to a golden brown before moving on to the next step. It's key to getting the perfect flavor (trust me, I tried without doing this).
- Don't burn the spices. Do not leave the whole spices or ground spices alone in butter for more than a minute, otherwise they will burn.
- Knowing when to blend. The makhani sauce is ready to blend when it's dry-ish and the tomatoes will darken by several shades (refer to the process shot). It'll look like a thick gravy. There will be small pools of butter coming out of the edges.
- Glass blender? Be careful! If you have a glass blender, you'll want to let the unblended makhani sauce cool for a bit before transferring it otherwise the glass may explode.
- Grainy makhani sauce? If the makhani sauce is grainy after blending, it's probably because there was too much onion. Add a tablespoon of water at a time to the blender until the sauce is completely smooth like in the process shot above.
- Bland makhani sauce. If you taste the makhani sauce before adding the chicken, you may find yourself unimpressed! It could have a very strong tomato taste at this point. You'll want to taste the makhani sauce after adding the chicken and the residual juices and spices from the pan. This adds a TON of flavor and will round out the dish. Otherwise, you may want to start by adjusting the salt or adding small amounts of garam masala and ground coriander.
- Too heavy on spices. If the opposite is true, the spices may have simmered for too long. Add another tablespoon of tomato paste or more heavy cream.
- Why are cashews optional? Cashews are a great way to add creaminess and a bit of nutty flavor to this curry. In fact, you could even omit the heavy cream if you really wanted to. If you do, I'd recommend soaking unsalted and unroasted cashews in water for 30 minutes to an hour before making the curry.
Storage Instructions
If you somehow have leftovers, don't miss this Butter Chicken Garlic Naan Pizza! We use the leftover butter chicken as a sauce and topping for a delicious pizza made with a naan crust. We also love Butter Chicken Naan-chos!! You only need about a cup of leftovers!
It can also be made ahead and stored for up to 5 days in an airtight container in the refrigerator. The flavors will only deepen over time.
The sauce will be really thick after refrigerating but will loosen up after reheating. Simply reheat on the stovetop in a saucepan by bringing it up to a simmer for 5-7 minutes, or until completely warmed through. Or reheat in the microwave with the lid on for 2 minutes at High power.
More Indian Curry Recipes to try
Recipe
Want to Save This Recipe?
Thinking about making this recipe? Enter your email and I'll send it straight to your inbox to save for later. Plus, get new recipe inspiration from me every week!
By submitting this form, you consent to receive emails from Masala and Chai.
Butter Chicken (Murgh Makhani)
Ingredients
Marinade
- 2 lbs chicken thighs, cubed
- ½ cup dahi, *see notes
- ½ lemon, juiced
- 2 tablespoon ginger garlic paste
- 1 green chili, finely chopped (optional)
- ½ teaspoon garam masala
- ¼ teaspoon ground turmeric
- ½ teaspoon ground cumin
- 1 tablespoon Kashmiri chili powder
- 1 teaspoon salt
Butter Chicken Sauce
- 4 tablespoon butter, divided
- 1 small yellow onion, chopped
- 1 star anise
- 1 black cardamom pod
- 4-5 green cardamom pods
- 1 cinnamon stick
- ½ teaspoon cumin seeds
- 1 tablespoon ginger garlic paste
- ½ teaspoon garam masala
- 1 teaspoon ground coriander
- ⅛ teaspoon ground cloves
- 1 tablespoon Kashmiri chili powder
- 1 tablespoon tomato paste
- 14 oz canned tomatoes
- 1 teaspoon sugar
- salt, to taste
- 5-8 cashews, optional
- ¼ cup heavy cream
- 1 teaspoon kasuri methi
- cilantro, red onion, heavy cream, to garnish
Instructions
- Trim the fat from the chicken thighs. Cube the chicken into 1-inch pieces.
- In a large bowl, mix together the items for the marinade - the dahi, lemon juice, ginger garlic paste, finely chopped green chilis, garam masala, turmeric, ground cumin, kashmiri chili powder, and salt. Once the marinade is ready, add the chicken into the bowl and toss so that it's fully coated.
- Cover the chicken with plastic wrap and marinate for a minimum of 30 minutes, up to 24 hours.
- Crush the green cardamom pods in a mortar and pestle or under the flat of a knife. Remove the black seeds inside the pod and discard the green part.
- Melt two tablespoons of butter in a pot on medium heat. Add the star anise, black cardamom, seeds from the green cardamom pods, cinnamon stick, and cumin seeds and allow the flavor to infuse with the butter for a minute.
- Add the chopped onions and ginger garlic paste into the butter. Sauté until the onions start to brown.
- Add the ground spices - the garam masala, coriander, cloves, and kashmiri chili powder. Give everything a good stir and let it cook for 1 minute so the spices can bloom in the butter. Don't let them sit for longer, otherwise the spices will burn.
- Stir in the tomato paste, canned crushed tomatoes, cashews (optional), sugar, and salt to taste.
- Switch the stove to low to medium heat, and allow the sauce to simmer. It'll start to thicken and darken significantly. This can take 5-10 minutes. The fat will start to release on the sides and form little pools. Switch the heat off.
- While the sauce is simmering in the step above, heat the cast iron skillet on high heat. Add a tablespoon of ghee or neutral oil in the pan and add in the marinated chicken. Cook on each side for 3-4 minutes until it reaches an internal temperature of 165 ºF and the chicken has browned. Set aside once done.
- Remove and discard the black cardamom pod, star anise, and cinnamon stick. Transfer the contents of the pot into a blender along with the rest of the butter. Blend the sauce until it's completely smooth. If it's too thick, add a tablespoon of water at a time. Add up to a ½ cup of hot water based off of preference if you'd like a looser curry.
- Transfer the sauce back into the pan and bring it back to a soft simmer. Add the chicken with all of the juices and spices into the pan. Stir to coat and simmer for an additional 5 minutes, until the fat begins to separate again.
- Slowly pour in the heavy cream while stirring. Continue to simmer for 2-3 minutes until the sauce is thick and creamy. This is a great point to taste and adjust for spices.
- Remove from heat and finish off the sauce with a pinch of kasuri methi. Crush the dried leaves between your hands to extract the flavor before adding it directly into the curry.
- Garnish the butter chicken with heavy cream, cilantro, and finely diced red onions. Serve hot with rice or garlic naan.
Notes
- If you have a glass blender, be very careful adding the hot contents of the pan into it otherwise it may break! You may need to allow it to cool a bit before blending, or use an immersion blender.
- If, for some reason, the spices aren't accessible, I'd highly recommend the MDH Butter Chicken Masala. Use a quarter of the box for the marinade, and another quarter for the makhani sauce. I adjust the MDH masala with an additional 1 teaspoon garam masala, ⅛ teaspoon ground cloves, ½ teaspoon cumin, ½ teaspoon freshly ground green cardamom, and ½ teaspoon coriander to the makhani sauce.
- The servings are listed as 4-6 depending on what you are serving the butter chicken with. A typical Indian household will serve butter chicken family-style with several other dishes and sides that will accommodate up to 6 people.
Annie Anger says
Absolutely exquisite! I can't remember ever having had better in a restaurant. The instructions are very clear. The only change I will make next time is to add the ginger and garlic paste after the onions are browned, so I don't have to worry about potentially burning the garlic. So good!
Shweta Garg says
Annie, isn't it ridiculously good?! I'm so happy to hear you found it easy to follow!! And that's definitely a good note on the ginger garlic paste. -Shweta
Mark H. says
Hello, I am planning on making this for my family while I visit for Thanksgiving. Unfortunately, I cannot get all the spices easily in my area, so I am going to go the premade blend route. Your notes suggest using half the MDH Butter Chicken Masala box, but link appears to be broken. Were you referring to the 3.5 oz box?
Thanks!
Shweta Garg says
Mark, I love that this is in your Thanksgiving plans! Yes - it's the 3.5oz box of MDH Butter Chicken Masala. I've updated the links in the post as well, thanks for pointing that out! I hope you and the fam love it. -Shweta
Andy says
Great recipe. Can we freeze it and if its too hot do you think adding more cream will help?
Shweta Garg says
Hi Andy, you can definitely freeze it but due to the cream it may be slightly grainy when you unthaw it. For the best success, reheat slowly over low heat in a sauce pan, stir often, and add a splash of cream or 1–2 tsp of butter while reheating to bring it back together. You can also freeze a portion without cream if you know you won't use it all, then stir in the cream while reheating. I hope that helps! -Shweta
Lindsey says
Okay so I knew this was going to be good based on all the amazing reviews and comments, so I went ahead and tripled the recipe. I followed it exactly, except I did opt to bake my chicken instead of pan frying it since I had so much to cook. I used the broiler tip and it came out perfectly!
Now about the finished recipe as a whole....
OMG THIS IS SO GOOD!!! Seriously, it's so cozy, comforting, filling, and delicious paired with a bowl of rice...I am so happy I made so much extra because I'll be enjoying eating this for a while lol!! I easily found all the ingredients at my local Indian market and even the grocer who helped me locate everything said this recipe was the real deal, haha!
Thank you for writing such a well-detailed recipe; your incredible instructions and photos made it a very straightforward process! Can't wait to make the butter chicken pizza and naanchos next!!!
Shweta Garg says
Lindsey, I'm so grateful for you sharing how easy the process was! Between heading to the Indian store to keep the ingredients authentic and sending me a pic of your huge vat of butter chicken... it made me so happy. You're the best! -Shweta
Anonymous says
Joy Asher says
I wish I had found your recommendations before making mine too spicy tonight. I went on an adventure to the Indian grocery and found the MDH spice mix , but I used almost the whole box oops. I also made a spinach with Paneer recipe to accompany it. The flavor was amazing but a bit too hot for me , now I know why !
Shweta Garg says
Oops! Well you know for next time 🙂 Also recommend serving it with a raita or add more heavy cream if you need to make it less spicy! - Shweta
Deanna Rudolph says
Let me say that this was my first attempt at making Butter Chicken. Your instructions and extra tips are impeccable. And, I did not just cook this; it was an EXPERIENCE! I followed your recipe EXACTLY, and with all of the whole spices and other ingredients involved; wow! The aroma blew me away! I made 8-times the given recipe in a big commercial aluminum kettle to take to a church event; feeding 40 people. Everyone LOVED it and couldn’t believe I had actually made it myself! With basmati rice, it was a hit! A fellow church goer from India even said it was the best Butter Chicken he has had since coming to the states! He even asked if I cooked it all day and I proudly told him “yes”!!! I am now converted to cooking Indian food! I am excited to try other recipes! Thank you so much!
Shweta Garg says
Deanna, I’m so glad you had a wonderful experience and everyone loved it!! This is exactly what I strive for and makes my heart so happy to hear. I can’t wait to see what else you make! Scaling it for 40 people is INCREDIBLE! xx, Shweta